The rules
How risk tiers and risk scores work
Why a system is high, medium or low risk, and how the 5 × 5 risk score is worked out.
AI Register uses two different measures of risk. A risk tier is worked out for each AI system from its answers. A risk score is given to each risk you record in the risk register.
Both use the same colours: red for high, amber for medium, green for low.
Risk tiers for AI systems
Each AI system gets a tier from your answers. The form shows the tier and the reasons as you fill it in.
High if either:
- it makes or informs decisions that significantly affect people; or
- it uses sensitive information: health, biometric or other sensitive information such as racial or ethnic origin, religion or criminal record.
Medium if it isn't high, and any of these are true:
- it uses personal information;
- it informs decisions about people, even minor ones;
- the vendor may train its models on your inputs, or you don't know whether it does;
- your data is processed or stored outside Australia.
Low otherwise, for example a tool used to draft marketing copy with no personal information.
Answering "Don't know" for vendor training makes a tool at least medium. Check vendor terms to find out and lower the risk where you can.
What the tier means
The tier tells you where to focus:
- High: do an impact assessment before it's used for real decisions, record its risks, and review it at least every six months.
- Medium: record its main risks and review it regularly.
- Low: keep it in the register and review it from time to time.
Risk scores in the risk register
In Risk register, you rate each risk on two scales from 1 to 5:
| Likelihood | Consequence |
|---|---|
| 1 Rare | 1 Insignificant |
| 2 Unlikely | 2 Minor |
| 3 Possible | 3 Moderate |
| 4 Likely | 4 Major |
| 5 Almost certain | 5 Severe |
The score is likelihood × consequence, from 1 to 25:
- 15 to 25: High. Needs a treatment plan, an owner and a due date.
- 6 to 14: Medium.
- 1 to 5: Low.
Open high risks are counted on the dashboard and in the board report.
AI Register gives guidance only, not legal advice. Still stuck? Contact us.